Statistics · Published
ERP ROI Statistics (2026): Sourced Numbers on Returns, Budgets and S/4HANA Migrations
Only 34% of SAP customers in SAPinsider's 2026 benchmark say their S/4HANA transition is complete, though 55% have deployed it.


Business cases for ERP programs promise a return, but the public evidence on whether that return arrives is thinner and less consistent than vendor material suggests. This roundup collects 2026 figures we could trace to a named publisher, with a focus on SAP and S/4HANA, and states the year and population for each.
Key takeaways
of respondents in SAPinsider's 2026 benchmark (296 organizations, fielded December 2025 to March 2026) had completed an S/4HANA transition
Source: SAPinsider, 2026
of SAP migrations ran over budget and behind schedule, in ISG's 2026 study of senior decision-makers at large companies
growth in SAP's current cloud backlog in Q3 2026 (26% at constant currencies), a vendor-reported sales signal
Source: SAP, Q3 2026 Quarterly Statement
of organizations in Panorama Consulting's 2026 ERP Report exceeded their project budgets, with added technology needs the leading cause
Adoption: where S/4HANA migrations stand
SAPinsider's 2026 benchmark is the largest recent sample in this roundup. The fieldwork covered 296 organizations between December 2025 and March 2026 (Datapace summary of the SAPinsider benchmark). Roughly 55% of those organizations have put S/4HANA or S/4HANA Cloud into use, yet only 34% describe the transformation as finished.
Source: SAPinsider, 2026
- A further 36% are still implementing, evaluating or building a business case; 4% have paused their project and 5% have no plans for S/4HANA at all (SAPinsider, 2026).
- Cloud is nearly level with on-premises: S/4HANA Cloud usage stands at 26%, close to the 29% share for traditional deployments (SAPinsider, 2026).
Source: SAPinsider, 2026
The Precisely and ASUG series shows the steadiest climb. Its share of SAP users who have fully or partly migrated rose each year, with another 23% expecting to finish within 24 months (Precisely and ASUG, November 2026).
Source: Precisely and ASUG, November 2026
ASUG's own 2026 member research uses a smaller sample and a different question. Of 194 members, 68% are live on S/4HANA or moving there (ASUG research as summarized by Lightrun, 2026). The 2025 ASUG figure was lower, at 56%, up from 45% in 2024 (CIO, reporting ASUG 2025 data).
Source: ASUG 2026 research, as summarized by Lightrun
Gartner's strictest measure is far lower. By Q4 2024, 39% of SAP's roughly 35,000 ECC customers had licensed S/4HANA (Gartner data, as reported by EasySAM, February 2026). Licensed, deployed and completed are different thresholds, which explains most of the spread in this section.
Source: Gartner via EasySAM, 2026 (data as of Q4 2024)
Timelines and the 2027 deadline
- ISG's respondents show about two-thirds still in planning, and 8% intend to stay on ECC beyond 2027 (ISG via EasySAM, February 2026).
- SAPinsider's 2026 respondents include 35% who plan to migrate during 2026, which the researchers flag as a looming talent constraint (SAPinsider, 2026).
- The share of ASUG members planning to wait more than two years fell from 22% in 2023 to 9% in 2025 (CIO, reporting ASUG data).
- Panorama's 2026 study, covering 170 organizations from January 2025 to January 2026, reports a nine-month median implementation timeline across ERP projects, not just S/4HANA (Xorosoft summary of Panorama, 2026).
Cost and budget outcomes
ISG's 2026 research, based on 200 senior decision-makers, puts overruns at the center of S/4HANA economics. Nearly 60% of SAP migrations are behind schedule and over budget, mostly because of underestimated complexity, expanding scope and limited internal capacity (ISG, February 2026). The split between those outcomes is below.
Source: ISG 2026 research, as summarized by Lightrun
Fewer than one in five organizations reimplement SAP processes and technology when they move to S/4HANA, according to the same ISG survey (ISG via EasySAM, February 2026). Budget pressure is also rising. ASUG's 2025 research recorded budget-pressure complaints up seven points year over year (CIO, reporting ASUG 2025). The research director attributed that pressure mainly to S/4HANA projects themselves (same CIO article).
Panorama's project-level breakdown is drawn from 170 organizations. Roughly 23% finished slightly over budget, 7% significantly over, and 19% under expected cost (Xorosoft summary of Panorama 2026 data). Panorama's own release describes the result as more than a quarter exceeding budget, so the two readings are consistent.
Source: Panorama Consulting 2026 ERP Report, as summarized by Xorosoft
Conflict to note: a Horváth study, as summarized by SoftwareSeni, is reported to show about 60% of SAP migrations exceeding budget, a composite of severe and moderate overruns (SoftwareSeni, 2026). We could not retrieve the Horváth report itself, so we present it as secondhand.
Historical context matters for cost. Flyvbjerg's ERP sample of 1,612 projects has a mean cost overrun ratio of 1.3 and a median of 0.9, which means the typical project came in under its estimate (Adoption Layer compilation of Flyvbjerg's ERP data). The 2012 McKinsey and University of Oxford study, which is historical, reported 45% of IT projects over budget, 7% over time and 56% delivering less value than predicted, for projects above $15 million (Adoption Layer, historical 2012 entry).
Failure rates and definitions
The most-quoted failure range is a poor guide because each study defines failure differently. Independent research puts failure or significant overrun at roughly 50% to 75%, depending on the definition (ERP Research, 2026). That same compilation states that no credible single 2026 failure rate exists (ERP Research, 2026).
Prosci's 2025 study uses a benefits-based definition. A project counts as failed if it delivers less than 70% of expected benefits, and under that definition the failure rate runs between 11% and 31% (Prosci data as summarized by Xorosoft). That range is far lower than the overrun-based figures above, so the definition decides the headline.
Some commonly cited figures are unverified. A Gartner prediction that more than 70% of recently implemented ERP initiatives will fall short of original goals by 2027 circulates through secondary sites (ConcordERP, 2025). We could not locate the underlying Gartner document, so we have not used it as a headline figure.
ROI: what the data does and does not show
We found no recent primary benchmark that reports a verified average ERP return on investment. The figure most often repeated, an average ROI of 52%, is attributed to DocuClipper and SoftwareSuggest by one compilation (Parsimony, 2026) and to ERP Peers by another (Kreative Core Tech, 2026). We could not trace either to an original study, so we have excluded it.
The closest verifiable ROI signal is conditional. Among organizations that ran an ROI analysis before implementation and had been live more than a year, 83% said results met or exceeded expectations. Secondary sites attribute that figure to Panorama (Parsimony, 2026). The Panorama 2026 release we reviewed does not contain it, so treat it as unconfirmed until you can see the full report.
Several widely shared numbers also trace to circulating blogs. A 73% failure rate for discrete manufacturing and 215% average overruns are attributed to Panorama (Godlan, 2026). An independent review states that neither figure appears on Panorama's most recent published study (NawaOne, 2026). We have excluded both.
For sign-off purposes, the defensible position is to build your own baseline. Use the ISG cause list, and the ASUG delay causes in the next section, to test your business case rather than benchmarking against an unverified average.
Testing and quality
ASUG's 2026 research looked at members who hit delays. Among the 36% reporting delays, the causes were business changes (55%), unexpected complexity (45%), scope creep (42%), testing (37%) and data issues (34%) (ASUG 2026 research, as summarized by Lightrun).
Source: ASUG 2026 research, as summarized by Lightrun (share of the 36% reporting delays)
ISG recommends that enterprises keep independent oversight of data readiness, integration testing and change management, and assign delivery ownership explicitly across vendors (ISG, February 2026). Precisely and ASUG's 2025 survey also found that process complexity is the top obstacle to automation, and that data quality is a migration challenge teams often overlook (Precisely and ASUG survey, 2025, reported by TechIntelPro).
AI and automation
AI is the newest claimed source of ROI, and the evidence remains thin. ASUG's 2025 data indicate that 10% of members have achieved an enterprise-scale AI rollout (CIO, reporting ASUG 2025 data). ISG warns that many SAP migrations skip the process and data re-engineering that automation and operational AI depend on (ISG, February 2026).
Source: Precisely and ASUG survey, 2025, reported by TechIntelPro
SAPinsider reports that enterprise AI has overtaken the 2027 maintenance deadline as the main external factor shaping cloud ERP strategy (SAPinsider, 2026). Treat that as a planning signal, not a measured return.
Vendor outlook: SAP's own numbers
SAP's Q3 2026 results give the vendor's view of demand. Current cloud backlog reached €24.1 billion, up 28% (26% at constant currencies) (SAP, Q3 2026). The same statement reports Cloud ERP Suite revenue up 29%, cloud revenue up 26% and total revenue up 13% (SAP, Q3 2026).
Source: SAP, Q3 2026 Quarterly Statement (reported growth; bars scaled to the largest value)
Software support revenue fell 5% in the quarter, and SAP expects that decline to accelerate as more customers move to the cloud (WebProNews on SAP Q3 2026). SAP now expects 2026 cloud revenue toward the upper end of its €25.8 billion to €26.2 billion range (WebProNews on SAP Q3 2026). These are vendor sales figures. They describe SAP's bookings, not the return any one customer earns.
What this means for your sign-off
- Baseline your own case. The public ROI averages do not hold up to source checks, so require a documented pre-implementation ROI baseline and a post-go-live measurement plan before sign-off.
- Budget for the causes, not the averages. ISG ties most overruns to complexity, scope and capacity. Put those three risks in the program register with named owners and triggers.
- Fund testing as an explicit line. Testing was cited by 37% of ASUG members who hit delays. Build the testing effort and the CoE into the business case rather than the contingency. The SAP Testing CoE operating model covers roles and funding.
- Keep independent oversight of integration testing and data readiness. ISG's governance advice applies directly to multi-vendor migrations. Map your test phases using the ECC to S/4HANA migration testing plan.
- Time the program against the maintenance calendar. With 35% of SAPinsider respondents planning to migrate in 2026, resource competition will be real. Check your dates against ECC end of maintenance and the S/4HANA migration by the numbers.
- Decide on edition early. Cloud and traditional deployments are nearly even in the SAPinsider sample, so the edition choice changes your test scope, upgrade cadence and regression plan.
Frequently asked questions
What share of SAP customers have finished an S/4HANA transition?
In SAPinsider's 2026 benchmark, 34% of respondents report a completed transition, while 55% have deployed S/4HANA or S/4HANA Cloud in some form (SAPinsider, 2026).
How many SAP migrations run over budget?
ISG's 2026 study found 58% of SAP migrations over budget and behind schedule, with 15% finishing on time and on budget (ISG via Lightrun, 2026).
What is the ERP failure rate?
It depends on the definition. Independent research puts failure or significant overrun at about 50% to 75% (ERP Research, 2026), while Prosci's benefits-based definition yields 11% to 31% (Prosci via Xorosoft, 2025).
What is the average ERP ROI?
We could not verify a primary average. One widely repeated figure of 52% traces only to secondary compilations (Parsimony, 2026). The most defensible conditional figure is 83% of organizations that ran pre-implementation ROI analysis, reported secondhand as Panorama data (Parsimony, 2026).
How much of the SAP ECC base had moved to S/4HANA?
By Q4 2024, 39% of SAP's roughly 35,000 ECC customers had licensed S/4HANA, according to Gartner data reported by EasySAM (EasySAM, February 2026).
How long do ERP implementations take?
Panorama's 2026 data, covering 170 organizations, reports a nine-month median timeline across ERP projects (Xorosoft summary of Panorama, 2026). S/4HANA programs in the ISG sample ran longer overall, but ISG did not publish an equivalent median.
Sources
- SAPinsider Benchmark Research: ERP Migration and Transformation 2026, SAPinsider, 2026
- 2026 SAP S/4HANA Migration: Navigating the Cloud and AI Bottleneck, SAPinsider, 2026
- ERP data migration: 55% deployed, 34% done, 16 months left, Datapace, 2026
- Precisely and ASUG survey finds 67% of SAP users have fully or partly migrated to S/4HANA, Compare the Cloud, November 5, 2026
- Precisely Survey: SAP S/4HANA Migration Pace Accelerates, TechIntelPro (reporting the Precisely and ASUG 2025 survey), 2025
- SAP customers say migration is eating their budgets, and AI is next in line, CIO (reporting ASUG data), 2025
- S/4HANA Migration: Keep Your SAP Landscape Stable, Lightrun (summarizing ASUG 2026 and ISG 2026 research), 2026
- Firms Moving to SAP S/4HANA Prioritize Short-Term Stability Over Long-Term Transformation: ISG Study, ISG, February 2, 2026
- Most SAP migrations bust budgets and project timelines, research finds, EasySAM (reporting ISG and Gartner data), February 6, 2026
- Panorama Consulting Group Releases Latest Study of ERP Implementation Outcomes, Panorama Consulting Group, March 4, 2026
- ERP Implementation Statistics 2026: Timelines, Overruns, and Migration Patterns, Xorosoft (summarizing Panorama 2026), 2026
- ERP Implementation Failure Statistics: 2026 Data and Risks, Xorosoft (summarizing Panorama 2026 and Prosci 2025), 2026
- ERP implementation failure rate: 12 studies compared, Adoption Layer (compiling McKinsey 2012 and Flyvbjerg ERP data), undated
- ERP Failure Statistics and Case Studies (2026), ERP Research, 2026
- ERP Implementation Failures: Stats, Cases and Market Share, ConcordERP, 2025
- Why SAP Migrations Fail at a Rate That Should Concern Every Decision Maker, SoftwareSeni, 2026
- ERP Statistics 2026: Market, ROI, AI Trends, Parsimony, 2026
- 58 Must-Know ERP Statistics for 2026, Kreative Core Tech, 2026
- The ERP "Failure Rate" Myth vs. Panorama's Real Data, NawaOne, 2026
- ERP Implementation Failure Statistics: 2026 Research, Godlan, 2026
- SAP Quarterly Statement Q3 2026, SAP, October 21, 2026
- SAP Tops €10 Billion in Quarterly Revenue for the First Time as Cloud Revenue Rises 26%, WebProNews, October 2026
Last updated: November 20, 2026. Statistics are refreshed as new research is published.
Free SAP testing templates
Master test strategy, UAT sign-off, cutover runbook, go/no-go checklist and more.
Get the weekly newsletter
New statistics, practitioner stories and templates, once a week.
More statistics
How this page is made: statistics are gathered from published research with AI-assisted search, every figure is linked to its source, and the page is refreshed as new data is published. Found an error? Tell us.